H.R. 3952 — what changed

added “(d)

added “(1) There is in the Administration a Chief Scientist of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (in this subsection referred to as the “Chief Scientist”), who shall be selected by the Administrator and compensated at the rate now or hereafter provided for Level V of the Executive Schedule pursuant to section 5316 of title 5, United States Code. In selecting a Chief Scientist, the Administrator shall give due consideration to any recommendations for candidates which may be submitted by the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Science Advisory Board, and other widely recognized, reputable, and diverse United States scientific or academic bodies, including minority serving institutions or other such bodies representing underrepresented populations. The Chief Scientist shall be the principal scientific adviser to the Administrator on science and technology policy and strategy, as well as scientific integrity, and shall perform such other duties as the Administrator may direct. The Chief Scientist shall be an individual who is, by reason of scientific education and experience, knowledgeable in the principles of scientific disciplines associated with the work of the Administration, and who has produced work of scientific merit through an established record of distinguished service and achievement.

added “(2) The Chief Scientist shall—

added “(A) adhere to any agency or department scientific integrity policy and—

added “(i) provide written consent to all applicable scientific integrity and other relevant science and technology policies of the Administration prior to serving in such position, with such written consent to be made available on a publicly accessible website of the Administration;

added “(ii) in conjunction with the Administrator and other members of Administration leadership, undergo all applicable training programs of the Administration which inform employees of their rights and responsibilities regarding the conduct of scientific research and communication with the media and the public regarding scientific research; and

added “(iii) in coordination with the Administrator and other members of Administration leadership, make all practicable efforts to ensure Administration employees and contractors who are engaged in, supervise, or manage scientific activities, analyze or communicate information resulting from scientific activities, or use scientific information in policy, management, or regulatory decisions, adhere to established scientific integrity policies of the Administration;

added “(B) provide policy and program direction for science and technology priorities of the Administration and facilitate integration and coordination of research efforts across line offices of the Administration, with other Federal agencies, and with the external scientific community, including through—

added “(i) leading the development of a science and technology strategy of the Administration and issuing policy guidance to ensure that overarching Administration policy is aligned with science and technology goals and objectives;

added “(ii) chairing the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Science Council and serving as a liaison to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Science Advisory Board;

added “(iii) providing oversight to ensure—

added “(I) the Administration funds high priority and mission-aligned science and technology development, including through partnerships with the private sector, Cooperative Institutes, academia, nongovernmental organizations, and other Federal and non-Federal institutions; and

added “(II) there is no unnecessary duplication of such science and technology development;

added “(iv) ensuring the Administration attracts, retains, and promotes world class scientists and researchers from diverse backgrounds, experiences, and expertise;

added “(v) promoting the health and professional development of the Administration’s scientific workforce, including by promoting efforts to reduce assault, harassment, and discrimination that could hamper such health and development; and

added “(vi) ensuring coordination across the scientific workforce and its conduct and application of science and technology with the Administration’s most recent Diversity and Inclusion Strategic Plan;

added “(C) under the direction of the Administrator, promote, communicate, and advocate for the Administration’s science and technology portfolio and strategy to the broad domestic, Tribal, and international communities and Congress, represent the Administration in promoting and maintaining good public and community relations, and provide the widest practical and appropriate dissemination of science and technology information concerning the full range of the Administration’s earth system authorities;

added “(D) manage an Office of the Chief Scientist—

added “(i) which shall be staffed by Federal employees of the Administration detailed to the office on a rotating basis, in a manner that promotes diversity of expertise, background, and to the extent practicable, ensures that each line office of the Administration is represented in the Office over time;

added “(ii) in which there shall be a Deputy Chief Scientist, to be designated by the Administrator or Acting Administrator from among the Assistant Administrators on a rotational basis, as appropriate to their backgrounds or expertise, who shall advise and support the Chief Scientist and perform the functions and duties of the Chief Scientist for not more than one year in the event the Chief Scientist is unable to carry out the duties of the Office, or in the event of a vacancy in such position; and

added “(iii) which may utilize contractors pursuant to applicable laws and regulations, and offer opportunities to fellows under existing programs; and

added “(E) not less frequently than once each year, in coordination with the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Science Council, produce and make publicly available a report that—

added “(i) describes the Administration’s implementation of the science and technology strategy and scientific accomplishments from the past year;

added “(ii) details progress toward goals and challenges faced by the Administration’s science and technology portfolio and scientific workforce;

added “(iii) provides a summary of Administration-funded research, including—

added “(I) the percentage of Administration-funded research that is funded intramurally;

added “(II) the percentage of Administration-funded research that is funded extramurally, including the relative proportion of extramural research that is carried out by—

added “(aa) the private sector;

added “(bb) Cooperative Institutes;

added “(cc) academia;

added “(dd) nongovernmental organizations; and

added “(ee) other categories as necessary; and

added “(III) a summary of Administration-funded research that is transitioned to operations, applications, commercialization, and utilization; and

added “(iv) provides reporting on scientific integrity actions, including by specifying the aggregate number of scientific and research misconduct cases, the number of consultations conducted, the number of allegations investigated, the number of findings of misconduct, and a summary of actions in response to such findings.

added “(3) Nothing in this subsection may be construed as impeding the ability of the Administrator to select any person for the position of Chief Scientist the Administrator determines is qualified to serve in such position.”

removed Section 2(d) of Reorganization Plan No. 4 of 1970 (5 U.S.C. App) is amended—

removed “(1)

removed “(A) provide written consent to all applicable scientific integrity policies of the Administration prior to appointment, with such written consent to be made available on a publicly accessible website of the Administration;

removed “(B) in conjunction with the Administrator and other members of Administration leadership, undergo all applicable training programs of the Administration which inform employees of their rights and responsibilities regarding the conduct of scientific research and communication with the media and the public regarding scientific research; and

removed “(C) in coordination with the Administrator and other members of Administration leadership, make all practicable efforts to ensure that Administration employees and contractors who are engaged in, supervise, or manage scientific activities, analyze or communicate information resulting from scientific activities, or use scientific information in policy, management, or regulatory decisions, adhere to established scientific integrity policies of the Administration;

removed “(2) provide policy and program direction for science and technology priorities at the Administration and facilitate integration and coordination of research efforts across line offices of the Administration, with other Federal agencies, and with the external scientific community, including through—

removed “(A) leading the development of science strategy at the Administration and issuing policy guidance to ensure that overarching Administration policy is aligned with science goals and objectives;

removed “(B) chairing the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Science Council and serving as principal liaison to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Science Advisory Board;

removed “(C) providing oversight to ensure that the Administration funds only the highest-priority, most exemplary, meritorious, and mission-driven science, including through partnerships with the private sector, Cooperative Institutes, academia, non-governmental organizations, and other Federal and non-Federal institutions, and that there is no duplication of research efforts;

removed “(D) ensuring the Administration attracts, retains, and promotes world class scientists and researchers;

removed “(E) promoting the health and professional development of the Administration’s scientific workforce; and

removed “(F) advancing diversity, equity, and inclusion in the Administration’s scientific workforce and its conduct and application of science;

removed “(3) under the direction of the Administrator, promote, communicate, and advocate for the Administration’s science portfolio and strategy to the broad external and international community and Congress, represent the Administration in promoting and maintaining good public and community relations, and provide the widest practical and appropriate dissemination of information concerning the climate, weather, oceans, fisheries, and coasts;

removed “(4) manage an Office of the Chief Scientist—

removed “(A) which shall be staffed by rotating career employees of the Administration, serving terms not greater than four years, in a manner that promotes diversity, equity, inclusion, leadership, and professional development, such that, to the maximum extent practicable, each line office of the Administration is given equal representation in the Office over time; and

removed “(B) in which one of the career employees described in subparagraph (A) shall serve as Deputy Chief Scientist, who shall perform the functions and duties of the Chief Scientist in the event the latter is unable to carry out the duties of the office, or in the event of a vacancy in the office; and

removed “(5) not less frequently than once each year, in coordination with the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Science Council, produce and make publicly available a report that—

removed “(A) describes scientific accomplishments of the Administration from the past year;

removed “(B) details progress towards goals and challenges faced by the Administration’s research and development portfolio, including bibliometrics and other measures of scientific merit, and progress towards improving diversity, equity, and inclusion in the Administration’s scientific workforce;

removed “(C) provides a summary of Administration-funded research, including—

removed “(i) the percentage of Administration-funded research that is funded intramurally;

removed “(ii) the percentage of Administration-funded research that is funded extramurally, including the relative proportion of extramural research that is carried out by each of the following:

removed “(I) the private sector;

removed “(II) Cooperative Institutes;

removed “(III) academia;

removed “(IV) non-governmental organizations; and

removed “(V) other categories as necessary; and

removed “(iii) a summary of Administration-funded research that is transitioned to operations, applications, commercialization, and utilization; and

removed “(D) provides reporting on scientific integrity actions, including by specifying the aggregate number of scientific and research misconduct cases, the number of consultations conducted, the number of allegations that were investigated, and the number of findings of misconduct.”