H.R. 2471 — what changed
Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2022
From Introduced in House to Engrossed in House. 6 sections amended between Introduced in House and Engrossed in House.
Sec. 2 Findings
Congress finds the following:
On January 12, 2010, a massive earthquake struck near the Haitian capital city of Port-au-Prince, leaving at least 220,000 people dead, including 103 United States citizens, 101 United Nations personnel, and nearly 18 percent of Haiti’s civil service, as well as 300,000 injured, 115,000 homes destroyed, and 1,500,000 Haitians displaced.
The international community, led by the United States and the United Nations, mounted an unprecedented humanitarian response to the earthquake in Haiti. Through 2018, more than $8,000,000,000 has been disbursed by donors. Since the 2010 earthquake, the United States Government has disbursed more than $4,000,000,000 in recovery and development funding.
On October 4, 2016, Hurricane Matthew struck southwestern Haiti on the Tiburon Peninsula, causing widespread damage and flooding and leaving 1.4 million people in need of immediate assistance. Recovery efforts continue more than four years later.
changed
Prior to both the 2010 earthquake and 2016 hurricane, Haiti registered among the lowest in socioeconomic indicators and had the second highest rate of income disparity in the world—conditions that have further complicated disaster recovery and resilience efforts. As of November 2020, 4,400,000 people are were in need of humanitarian assistance in Haiti.
removed
With United States assistance, more than 30,000 jobs have been created since the 2010 earthquake, largely in the apparel industry at the Caracol Industrial Park (in partnership with the Inter-American Development Bank, the Haitian Government, and the private sector) in northern Haiti.
renumbered
was (8)
Since 2018, tens of thousands of Haitians have participated in popular demonstrations demanding accountability over government management of Petrocaribe resources. In early 2019, the Haitian superior court of auditors released a series of reports implicating high-level government officials in the misappropriation of funds.
added
The United Nations Human Rights Office of the High Commissioner and the Human Rights Service jointly found a 333 percent increase in human rights violations and abuses against the rights of life and security in Haiti from July 2018 through December 2019. There were 131 violations in 2018 and 567 violations in 2019, including the shooting of at least five Haitian journalists covering the protests.
removed
The United Nations Human Rights Office of the High Commissioner and the Human Rights Service jointly found a 333 percent increase in human rights violations and abuses against the rights of life and security from July 2018 through December 2019. There were 131 violations in 2018 and 567 violations in 2019, including the shooting of at least one journalist covering the protests.
renumbered
was (10)
Leading members of civil society have faced attacks, including Monferrier Dorval, a constitutional law expert and president of the Port-au-Prince bar who was killed on August 28, 2020.
added
On November 13, 2018, according to the Haitian National Human Rights Defense Network, at least 71 people were killed and 18 people were raped in the Port-au-Prince neighborhood of La Saline.
removed
On November 13, 2018, according to the Haitian National Human Rights Defense Network, at least 71 people were shot and killed and 18 people were raped in the Port-au-Prince neighborhood of La Saline.
renumbered
was (12)
On December 10, 2020, the Department of the Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control designated former Haitian National Police officer Jimmy Cherizier, former Director General of the Ministry of the Interior Fednel Monchery, and former Departmental Delegate Joseph Pierre Richard Duplan pursuant to the Global Magnitsky Executive Order for being foreign persons responsible for or complicit in, or having directly or indirectly engaged in, serious human rights abuse for their connection to the La Saline massacre.
renumbered
was (13)
Following the La Saline massacre, similar attacks have occurred in Port-au-Prince neighborhoods, including the November 2019 and August 2020 attacks on Bel Air, in which 24 people were killed and hundreds of families were displaced.
added
Parliamentary elections scheduled for October 2019 did not take place, and since January 13, 2020, President Jovenel Moïse has ruled by decree. The United States and international community have urged President Moise to limit the use of executive decrees during this period and have expressed concern over several decrees issued, including those creating the National Intelligence Agency and appointing three new judges to the Supreme Court outside of constitutional procedures. Haitian civil society organizations have denounced the president’s use of decrees as an attempt to consolidate power.
changed
Parliamentary elections scheduled for October 2019 did not take place, Due to institutional weakness and since January 13, 2020, President Jovenel Moïse has ruled other challenges exacerbated by decree. At least five decrees have been cited as increasingly authoritarian the COVID-19 pandemic, Haiti’s economy contracted by Haitian civic and political leaders an estimated 4 percent in 2020 and the international community, including the October 30, 2020, decision to constitute a five-member group to draft a new constitution, the November 6, inflation neared 20 percent. Although there has been no parliament in place since January 2020, decision to reduce the control of anti-corruption entities like the Superior Court of Accounts and Administrative Litigation, the November 26, 2020, anti-terrorism decree that establishes sanctions applicable to Haitian police officers not stopping demonstrations, Government approved a budget on September 30, 2020. However, the November 26, 2020, creation of delay prevented the National Intelligence Agency, International Monetary Fund and the February 11, 2021, appointment of three new judges to the Supreme Court of Haiti outside of constitutional procedures.other multilaterals from disbursing millions in international assistance.
changed
Although there has been no parliament in place since January 2020, the Haitian Government approved a budget on In September 30, 2020, but President Moïse bypassed the delay prevented Supreme Court to appoint a Provisional Electoral Council (CEP) by executive decree Several civil society groups that traditionally participate in Haiti’s electoral councils criticized the International Monetary Fund decision and other multilaterals from disbursing millions have declined to be represented in international assistance.the CEP.
changed
In September 2020, President The Moïse bypassed administration lacks the Supreme Court credibility to appoint oversee a Provisional Electoral Council (CEP) by executive decree. Several civil society groups that traditionally participate in Haiti’s electoral councils criticized the decision and have declined to be represented in the CEP.proposed constitutional referendum scheduled for June 2021, which legal experts consider unconstitutional.
changed
On There are concerns that, given the lack of democratic checks and balances, the dispute over the credibility of the electoral council, and the deteriorating security situation, elections scheduled for September 2021 will not be free or fair. Additionally, the security situation remains volatile and on February 7, 2021, President Moïse alleged that a coup had been attempted against him leading to 23 subsequent arrests, including of Judge Yviquel Dabrésil of the Supreme Court of Haiti. The Department of State noted that “the situation remains murky arrests and we await the results of the police investigation”. President Moïse later forced the retirement of three Supreme Court judges on February 9, 2021, who were named as possible transitional presidents by political opponents, and replaced them with individuals he unilaterally selected.judges.
Sec. 3 Statement of policy
It is the policy of the United States to support the sustainable rebuilding and development of Haiti in a manner that—
recognizes Haitian independence, self-reliance, sovereignty, democratic governance, and efficiency;
promotes efforts that are led by and support the people and Government of Haiti at all levels so that Haitians lead the course of reconstruction and development of Haiti;
changed
builds the long term long-term capacity of the Government of Haiti, civil society in Haiti, and the private sector to foster economic opportunities in Haiti;
fosters collaboration between the Haitian diaspora in the United States, including dual citizens of Haiti and the United States, with the Haitian Government and the business community in Haiti;
changed
supports anticorruption efforts anti-corruption efforts, promotes press freedom, and addresses human rights concerns;concerns, including through the enforcement of sanctions imposed in accordance with the Global Magnitsky Human Rights Accountability Act on individuals implicated in human rights violations;
respects and helps restore Haiti’s natural resources, as well as strengthens community-level resilience to environmental and weather-related impacts;
promotes the holding of free, fair, and timely elections in accordance with democratic principles and the Haitian Constitution;
changed
provides timely and comprehensive reporting on Haiti and the United States Government’s goals and progress, as well as transparent post program evaluations and contracting data; anddata;
changed
promotes the participation of Haitian women and youth in governmental and nongovernmental institutions and in economic development and governance assistance programs funded by the United States.States; and
added
does not provide support to facilitate the proposed June 2021 constitutional referendum, including through multilateral organizations.
Sec. 4 Strengthening human rights and anticorruption efforts in haiti and holding perpetrators of the la saline massacre accountable
Secretary of state prioritization— The Secretary of State shall prioritize the protection of human rights and anticorruption efforts in Haiti by the following methods:
Fostering strong relationships with independent civil society groups focused on monitoring corruption and human rights abuses and promoting democracy in Haiti.
Supporting the efforts of the Haitian Government to identify persons involved in human rights violations and significant acts of corruption in Haiti, including public and private sector actors, and hold them accountable for their actions.
Addressing concerns of impunity for the alleged perpetrators, as well as the intellectual authors, of the La Saline massacre.
changed
Urging authorities to continue to investigate attacks in the La Saline and Bel Air neighborhoods in from 2018 and 2019 that through 2021that left dozens dead in order to bring the perpetrators to justice.
Briefing—
Elements— Not later than 180 days after the date of the enactment of this Act, the Secretary of State shall brief the appropriate congressional committees on the happenings on November 13, 2018, in the Port-au-Prince neighborhood of La Saline, and its aftermath. The briefing shall include—
an examination of any links between the massacre in La Saline and mass protests that occurred concurrently in the country;
an analysis of the reports on the La Saline massacre authored by the United Nations, the European Union, and the Government of Haiti;
a detailed description of all known perpetrators, as well as the intellectual authors, of the shootings;
an overview of efforts taken by the Haitian Government to bring the perpetrators, as well as the intellectual authors, of the La Saline massacre to justice and to prevent other similar attacks; and
an assessment of the ensuing treatment and displacement of the survivors of the La Saline massacre.
Consultation— In the briefing required under paragraph (1), the Secretary of State shall consult with nongovernmental organizations in Haiti and the United States.
Sec. 5 Actions to promote freedom of the press and assembly in haiti
The Secretary of State shall prioritize the promotion of freedom of the press and freedom of assembly, as well as the protection of journalists in Haiti by the following methods:
Advocating to Haitian authorities for increased protection for journalists and the press and for the freedom to peacefully assemble or protest in Haiti.
changed
Collaborating with government officials and representatives of civil society to increase develop and implement legal protections for journalists in Haiti.
Supporting efforts to strengthen transparency in Haiti’s public and private sectors, as well as access to information in Haiti.
changed
Utilizing United States foreign assistance for programs Supporting efforts to strengthen the capacity for of independent journalists and increase support access to resources for investigative journalism.
Sec. 6 Actions to support post-earthquake, post-hurricane and post-covid–19 recovery and development in haiti
The Secretary of State, in coordination with the Administrator of the United States Agency for International Development (USAID), shall prioritize post-earthquake and post-hurricane recovery and development efforts in Haiti by the following methods:
Collaborating with the Haitian Government on a detailed and transparent development plan that includes clear objectives and benchmarks.
Building the capacity of Haitian-led public, private, and nongovernmental sector institutions in Haiti through post-earthquake and post-hurricane recovery and development planning.
changed
Assessing the impact of both the United States States’ and the international community’s recovery and development efforts in Haiti since January 2010.
Supporting disaster resilience and reconstruction efforts.
changed
Addressing the underlying causes of poverty and inequality.inequality, and improving access to health resources, clean water, food, and shelter.
changed
Improving access to—Assessing the impact of the COVID–19 pandemic on post-disaster recovery efforts and evaluating United States support to help with pandemic response efforts in Haiti, including providing technical assistance and preventing other infectious disease outbreaks.
removed
health resources;
removed
public health technical assistance; and
removed
clean water, food, and shelter.
removed
Assessing the impact of the COVID–19 pandemic on post-disaster recovery efforts and evaluating United States support needed to help with the pandemic response in Haiti.
Sec. 7 Report
Report content— Not later than 180 days after the date of the enactment of this Act, the Secretary of State, in coordination with the Administrator of the United States Agency for International Development, and other relevant agencies and departments, shall submit to the appropriate congressional committees a report that includes—
a strategy for carrying out the initiatives described in sections 4, 5, and 6, including established baselines, benchmarks, and indicators to measure outcomes and impact;
changed
an assessment of major corruption committed among the public and private sectors, and, as practical and on all appropriate, an assessment of corruption prosecutions investigated by the Haitian judiciary since January 2015;
an overview of efforts taken by the Haitian Government to address corruption, including the Petrocaribe scandal, and corrective measures to strengthen and restore trust in Haiti’s public institutions;
a description of United States Government efforts to consult and engage with Haitian Government officials and independent civil society groups focused on monitoring corruption and human rights abuses and promoting democracy and press freedom in Haiti since January 2015;
a description of the Haitian Government’s response to civic protests that have taken place since July 2018 and any allegations of human rights abuses, including attacks on journalists;
an assessment of United States security assistance to Haiti, including the United States support to the Haitian National Police and an assessment of compliance with section 620M of the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961 (22 U.S.C. 2378d) and section 362 of title 10, United States Code (commonly referred to as the “Leahy Laws”);
a description of the Haitian Government’s efforts to support displaced survivors of urban and gang violence;
an assessment of the impact of presidential decrees on the health of Haiti’s democratic institutions and safeguarding of human rights, including reducing the authority of the Superior Court of Accounts and Administrative Litigation, promulgating an antiterrorism law, and establishing the National Intelligence Agency, as well as retiring and subsequently appointing judges to the Supreme Court of Haiti;
changed
a review of plan in collaboration with the February 7, 2021, alleged coup against President Moïse and subsequent arrest and jailings of alleged perpetrators;Haitian Government on efforts to support development goals since January 2015, including steps taken to—
removed
an analysis in collaboration with the Haitian Government on efforts to support development goals since January 2015, including steps taken to—
renumbered
was (2)(12)(2)
strengthen institutions at the national and local levels; and
renumbered
was (2)(12)(3)
strengthen democratic governance at the national and local levels;
renumbered
was (2)(13)
an analysis of the effectiveness and sustainability of United States-financed development projects, including the Caracol Industrial Park and supporting infrastructure;
renumbered
was (2)(14)
a breakdown of procurement from Haitian small- and medium-sized businesses and nongovernmental organizations by the United States and Haitian governments for development and humanitarian activities by year since 2015, and a description of efforts to increase local procurement, including food aid;
added
a description of United States efforts taken since January 2010 to assist the Haitian people in their pursuits for free, fair, and timely democratic elections;
changed
a description of quantitative and qualitative indicators to assess progress and benchmarks for United States efforts taken since January 2010 to assist the Haitian people initiatives focused on sustainable development in their pursuits for free, fair, Haiti, including democracy assistance, economic revitalization, natural disaster recovery, pandemic response, resilience, energy and timely democratic elections; infrastructure, health, and food security; and
changed
quantitative and qualitative indicators to assess progress a risk assessment of conflict, instability, and benchmarks for United States initiatives focused on sustainable development violence in Haiti, including democracy assistance, economic revitalization, natural disaster recovery, pandemic response, resilience, energy and infrastructure, health, and food security.Haiti that includes information relating to—
added
systemic patterns and causes of violence and subsequent impunity relating to massacres, death threats, kidnappings, armed attacks, and firearm-related violence, with analysis of the roles of the various actors and beneficiaries who play a part, including Haitain Government actors;
added
gang activity and its role in the recent wave of kidnappings and the capacities of the police force to address the most serious manifestations of insecurity;
added
the scope and role of criminal activity and its linkages to political forces, particularly leading up to elections; and
added
implications of the lack of independence of Haiti’s judicial system.
Consultation— In preparing the report required under subsection (a), the Secretary of State and the USAID Administrator shall consult with nongovernmental organizations and civil society groups in Haiti and the United States, as well as the Government of Haiti where appropriate.
Public availability— The report required under subsection (a) shall be made publicly available on the website of the Department of State.