Patient Choice and Quality Care Act of 2017
A BILL
To amend title XVIII of the Social Security Act to provide for advanced illness care coordination services for Medicare beneficiaries, and for other purposes.
Sec. 2 Findings
Sec. 3 Advanced illness care and management model
“(h) Advanced illness care and management model
“(1) Model
“(A) In general—The model described in this subparagraph is a model under which payments are made under title XVIII to applicable providers that furnish advanced illness care and management services, including care coordination and palliative care services, to eligible individuals with serious, chronic progressive, or advanced illness in order to test the use of targeted advanced illness management and early use of palliative care under the Medicare program.
“(B) Voluntary—Participation under the model shall be voluntary with respect to both eligible individuals and applicable providers.
“(C) Requirements
“(i) Hospice provider—At least one applicable provider selected for participation under the model shall be a hospice program (as defined in section 1861(dd)(2)).
“(ii) Comparison—The Secretary shall establish the model in such a manner as will permit the comparison of outcomes for eligible individuals participating under the model and eligible individuals who are not so participating.
“(iii) Incorporation into existing models—In addition to operating the model independently, the Secretary shall incorporate the model into existing models related to the Medicare program, such as models involving accountable care organizations, bundled payments, and value based purchasing arrangements, and other coordinated care models as the Secretary determines to be appropriate.
“(2) Payments—Under the model, the Secretary shall establish payment amounts for advanced illness care and management services that is targeted to eligible individuals with a serious, chronic progressive, or advanced illness. The payments may include payments under a fee schedule, capitated payments, bundled payments, value-based purchasing agreements, and other payment mechanisms determined appropriate by the Secretary.
“(3) Advanced illness care and management services defined—In this subsection, the term “advanced illness care and management services” means the following services, as appropriate for the individual's illness and stage of illness:
“(A) One or more face-to-face encounters between one or more members of the interdisciplinary team and the individual and, at the individual’s discretion, family caregivers, or, for an individual who lacks decisionmaking capacity under State law, the individual’s legally authorized representative.
“(B) The provision of information about the typical trajectory of illnesses or conditions that affect the individual, including foreseeable care decisions that may need to be made at a future time when the individual is likely to be unable to make decisions due to temporary or permanent cognitive or medical incapacity.
“(C) Assisting the individual in defining and articulating goals of care, values, and preferences.
“(D) Providing the individual with and discussing information about the benefits and burdens of relevant ranges of treatment options available to the individual, including disease modifying or potentially curative treatment, palliative care, which may be provided alone or in conjunction with disease modifying treatment, and, when the individual may be currently eligible or may become eligible for hospice care due to disease progression.
“(E) Assisting the individual in evaluating treatment options and approaches to care to identify those that most closely align with the individual’s goals of care, values, and preferences.
“(F) Preparing, and sharing with relevant providers, documentation—
“(i) that states the individual’s goals of care, preferences, and values, preferred decisionmaking strategies, and a plan of care that is concrete and actionable; and
“(ii) that is in State or locally recognized forms that are used for the purpose of assuring that providers can follow the plan across care settings, such as advance directives or portable treatment orders.
“(G) Referrals to providers, including medical and social service providers, who deliver care consistent with the plan.
“(H) Providing culturally and educationally appropriate training for the individual and family caregivers to support their ability to carry out the plan.
“(I) A multidimensional assessment of the individual’s strengths and limitations.
“(J) An assessment of the individual’s paid and unpaid supports, including family caregivers.
“(K) Comprehensive medication review and management (including, if appropriate, counseling and self-management support).
“(L) Visits to the patient in all sites of care (including the home, a hospital, and a nursing home) as needed to respond appropriately to problems and concerns.
“(M) Additional services, consistent with the care plan, that the interdisciplinary team believes would assist the eligible individual and family caregivers in more effectively managing their health condition.
“(N) 24-Hour access to emergency support in person or via telephone or telemedicine with the individual’s medical record and care plan available to the responder.
“(O) Care coordination and communication across health care and social service settings and providers, including involvement of the interdisciplinary team to evaluate quality and address concerns over time.
“(P) Such other palliative and other services that the Secretary determines appropriate.
“(4) Applicable provider defined—In this subsection, the term applicable provider means a hospice program (as defined in section 1861(dd)(2)) or other provider of services (as defined in section 1861(u)) or supplier (as defined in section 1861(d)) that—
“(A) furnishes services through an interdisciplinary team; and
“(B) meets such other requirements the Secretary may determine to be appropriate.
“(5) Eligible individual defined—In this subsection, the term eligible individual means an individual who—
“(A) is entitled to, or enrolled for, benefits under part A of title XVIII and enrolled under part B of such title, but not enrolled under part C of such title;
“(B) resides at home or in an institutional setting, whichever is consistent with their personal goals and preferences; and
“(C) meets at least one of the following:
“(i) The individual has the need for assistance with two or more activities of daily living (defined as bathing, dressing, eating, getting out of bed or a chair, mobility, and toileting) that is caused by one or more serious or life threatening conditions or frailty and that is not associated with an acute or post-operative condition.
“(ii) The individual is diagnosed with a serious, chronic progressive or advanced illness that—
“(I) has a strong negative impact on the individual's quality of life and functioning in life roles, independent of its impact on mortality; or
“(II) is burdensome in symptoms, treatments or caregiver stress.
“(iii) The individual is diagnosed with—
“(I) metastatic or locally advanced cancer;
“(II) Alzheimer’s disease or another progressive dementia;
“(III) late-stage neuromuscular disease;
“(IV) late-stage diabetes;
“(V) late-stage kidney, liver, heart, gastrointestinal, cerebrovascular, or lung disease; or
“(VI) age-related physical debility.
“(iv) The individual meets other criteria determined appropriate by the Secretary.
“(6) Interdisciplinary team
“(A) In general—Subject to subparagraph (B), in this subsection, the term interdisciplinary team means a group that—
“(i) includes at least—
“(I) one physician who is board certified in geriatrics, internal medicine, or family medicine;
“(II) one physician, advance practice registered nurse, or physician assistant, who is a palliative specialist (defined as having a certification in hospice and palliative care) or who has at least one year’s experience providing hospice or palliative care;
“(III) one nurse; and
“(IV) one social worker;
“(ii) may include a chaplain, minister, or pastoral counselor;
“(iii) may include other direct care personnel (including pharmacists, dieticians, physical therapists, occupational therapists, and psychotherapists); and
“(iv) meets requirements that may be established by the Secretary.
“(B) Additional member at the request of the eligible individual—An applicable provider shall offer to the eligible individual (or the individual’s legally authorized representative when the individual has been found to lack decisional capacity) the opportunity to select either a chaplain affiliated with the applicable provider, a minister, or personal religious or spiritual advisor who can help to represent the individual’s goals, values, and preferences to serve as a core interdisciplinary team member at the individual’s (or legally authorized representative’s) request.”
Sec. 4 Quality measurement development and implementation
“(4) Increased coordination and alignment between the public and private sector with respect to quality measures regarding advanced illness, palliative, and end-of-life care
“(A) In general—The entity shall facilitate increased coordination and alignment between the public and private sector with respect to quality measures regarding advanced illness, palliative, and end-of-life care across the care settings and programs described in this section and across other services and care settings under this title, as appropriate.
“(B) Environmental scan—The entity shall conduct an environmental scan of measures, measure concepts, and preferred practices for advanced illness, palliative, and end-of-life care used in both the private and public sectors and from multiple settings of care. Such scan shall include a review of the following:
“(i) The process of eliciting and documenting patient (and, where relevant and appropriate, family caregiver or legally authorized representative) goals, preferences, and values regarding care and treatment, including the articulation of goals for end-of-life care that adequately reflect how the patient wants to live.
“(ii) The effectiveness, patient-centeredness (and, where relevant, family caregiver-centeredness), and adequacy of care plans, including documentation of individual goals, preferences, and values.
“(iii) Agreement and consistency among—
“(I) the patient’s goals, preferences, and values;
“(II) any documented care plan; and
“(III) the care delivered.
“(iv) Timely and appropriate referral to hospice care.
“(C) Identification and prioritization of measures—The entity shall, based on the scan conducted under subparagraph (B), identify and prioritize measures, measure concepts, and preferred practices, that are aligned across settings of care, condition, and patient population.
“(D) Report—Not later than 18 months after the date of enactment of this paragraph, the entity shall submit to the Secretary a report containing the findings of the entity with respect to the environmental scan under subparagraph (B) and the identification and prioritization of measures, measure concepts, and preferred practices under subparagraph (C).”
“(g) Study and report on NIH development of additional measures related to care planning
“(1) Study—The Secretary, in consultation with the Palliative Care Research Cooperative Group, the National Institute of Nursing Research, and the Office of End-of-Life and Palliative Care Research of the National Institutes of Health shall conduct a study regarding the development of measures related to—
“(A) concordance of care between the wishes of an individual and the treatment received by the individual, including documentation of such wishes in the medical record;
“(B) understanding the population with serious, chronic progressive, or advanced illness that would benefit from palliative care and advance care planning services; and
“(C) appropriate transitions to hospice care.
“(2) Report—Not later than December 31, 2019, the Secretary shall submit to Congress a report containing the results of the study conducted under paragraph (1).”
“(G) Clinical care measures relating to palliative and end-of-life care—Beginning after the completion of the environmental scan under section 1890(b)(4)(B), within one or more appropriate quality domains, the Secretary shall, in consultation with the entity with a contract under section 1890(a), establish appropriate clinical care measures relating to palliative and end-of-life care, including at least one measure for each of the areas studied under subparagraphs (A), (B), and (C) of section 1890A(g)(1).”
“(VI) with respect to the domain described in subsection (c)(1)(F) (relating to end-of-life care)—
“(aa) for PAC providers described in clauses (ii), (iii), and (iv) of paragraph (2)(A), October 1, 2020; and
“(bb) for PAC providers described in clauses (i) of such paragraph, January 1, 2021.”
“(F) The effectiveness, patient-centeredness (and, where relevant, family caregiver-centeredness), and adequacy of care plans and communications relating to such plans, including—
“(i) documentation of a patient’s goals, preferences, and values;
“(ii) agreement and consistency with respect to care among—
“(I) the patient’s goals, preferences, and values;
“(II) any documented care plan; and
“(III) the care delivered; and
“(iii) timely and appropriate referral to hospice care.”
“(C) Palliative and end-of-life care—The Secretary, in consultation with the National Committee for Quality Assurance, shall prioritize the development of standards for palliative and end-of-life care, including transition to hospice care, with respect to Medicare Advantage organizations under this part for use under the quality improvement program under paragraph (1) that are the equivalent of such standards in quality programs applicable to providers of services and suppliers under the original Medicare fee-for-service program under parts A and B.”
“(i) In general—The Secretary”
“(ii) Palliative and end-of-life care—The Secretary, in consultation with the entity with a contract under section 1890(a), shall ensure that quality performance standards established under this subparagraph include measures that apply to palliative and end-of-life care, including transition to hospice care.”
Sec. 5 Enhancing coverage of advance care planning services
“(jjj) Advance care planning services
“(1) The term advance care planning services means services identified as of the date of enactment of this subsection as Current Procedural Terminology (CPT) codes 99497 and 99498, and such codes as subsequently modified, that are furnished by a physician or other eligible practitioner (as determined by the Secretary).
“(2) For purposes of paragraph (1), the term eligible practitioner includes, in addition to a practitioner eligible to bill such CPT codes as of the date of enactment of this subsection, an individual who—
“(A) is a clinical social worker (as defined in subsection (hh)(1)); and
“(B) possesses—
“(i) a relevant care planning certification; or
“(ii) experience providing care planning conversations or similar services, as defined by the Secretary, in the course of their work.”
Sec. 6 Advance care planning support tools
“(4) information on—
“(A) care planning;
“(B) how individual goals, values, and preferences should be considered in framing a care plan; and
“(C) a range of approaches for treating serious, chronic progressive, or advanced illness, including disease modifying options, palliative care that supports individuals from the onset of illness and can be provided at the same time as all other care types, and hospice care; and
“(5) information on documentation options for care planning or advance care planning, including advance directives and portable treatment orders.”
Sec. 7 Advance directives
“(5)
“(A) An advance directive validly executed outside the State in which such directive is presented may be given effect by a provider of services or organization to the same extent as an advance directive validly executed under the law of the State in which it is presented.
“(B) In the absence of knowledge to the contrary, a physician or other health care provider or organization may presume that a written advance health care directive or similar instrument, regardless of where executed, is valid.
“(C) The provisions of this paragraph shall preempt any State law on advance directive portability to the extent such law is inconsistent with such provisions.
“(D) Nothing in the paragraph shall be construed to—
“(i) authorize the administration of health care treatment otherwise prohibited by the laws of the State in which the directive is presented;
“(ii) require a provider of services or an organization to act in a manner contrary to its religious or moral convictions;
“(iii) apply to a request or directive ordering a sterilization or abortion or ordering withdrawal of treatment from a pregnant woman if continued treatment can reasonably be expected to bring her child to live birth;
“(iv) prohibit the application of a State law which allows for an objection on the basis of conscience for any health care provider or any agent of such provider which as a matter of conscience cannot implement an advance directive or portable treatment order; or
“(v) permit the Secretary to seek civil penalties, including exclusion from participation in the program under this title or the program under title XIX, against a provider or organization if the provider or organization—
“(I) used reasonable efforts to deliver care that is consistent with an individual’s goals, preferences, and values when addressing decisionmaking for an individual who lacks decisional capacity; or
“(II) exercised its right of conscience in accordance with clause (ii) or (iv).”
“(2) to require any provider or organization, or any employee of such a provider or organization, to follow or be bound by a request from an individual or legally authorized representative, an advance directive, or a portable treatment order that directs the purposeful causing of, or the purposeful assisting in causing, the death of any individuals, such as by assisted suicide, euthanasia, or mercy killing.”
Sec. 8 Additional requirements for facilities
“(Z) in the case of hospitals, skilled nursing facilities, home health agencies, and hospice programs, to assure that documented care plans include any advance directives or portable treatment orders made while the individual received care by the provider and that such plan is sent to the individual’s primary care provider upon discharge and any facility to which the individual is transferred.”